The Washington Post reported today on an alleged cyberattack on an Illinois water plant. Apparently, the mischief succeeded in creating equipment malfunctions and consequent closure of the water facility. The attack's source was traced to a Russian IP address. The Post story relied for its key information from one source, an "industry security expert," whose due diligence found a report which outlined the incident and its immediate consequences.
(Postscript -- The Saturday, November 26th online edition of the Washington Post reports that the alleged attack on the Illinois water plant "was in fact caused by a plant contractor traveling in Russia." The story, released over the slow-news Thanksgiving weekend, also noted that "Plant and federal officials are still investigating the cause of the pump's failure." Why a contractor's computer activity could shut down a water plant's operation also remains unexplained.)
Regardless of this case's outcome, it does highlight what mayhem cyber warfare and industrial espionage can cause. For some time, the sources of most high-profile cyberattacks against American assets have been Russia, Eastern Europe, and the People's Republic of China. Israel and France have also conducted cyberattacks and state-supported espionage, principally to acquire sensitive corporate information, rather than disrupt the American security state.
Russian involvement has sinister and dangerous overtones, thanks to its blurring of boundaries between the state and the underworld. However, China is the most ominous state player, with its apparent imperialistic ambitions, aggressive will, and ample means to launch and maintain disruptive activity to American computer-based systems. Beijing's goals include the ability to defend itself against what it perceives as American electronic intrusion. This drive has manifested itself in episodes such as the Chinese government's continuing anti-Google campaign.
Meanwhile, there is increasing evidence that the United States empire is on a collision course with its emerging Chinese counterpart. As the Greek historian Thucydides observed, it is in the nature of hegemony for these conflicts to happen. The Chinese government and military have few doubts about this development. They're getting ready, looking for American weak spots, preparing to exploit advantage when the situation seems ripe for it. Meanwhile, our military-industrial complex and its governmental allies are slowly coming around to understanding the challenge's full dimensions. Ultimately, the American government will need to ally much more openly with its elite tech firms to counteract hostile, state-sponsored cyberwarfare. Whether Silicon Valley libertarians, DC technocrats, and military brass can coalesce to fight back against this shadow over American international dominance remains to be seen.
Showing posts with label industrial espionage. Show all posts
Showing posts with label industrial espionage. Show all posts
Friday, November 18, 2011
Saturday, September 3, 2011
Questions Swirl Around Vanished iPhone 5 Prototype, Apple Security Personnel's Alleged Illegal Search, and San Francisco Police Role In The Search
The long title (sorry about that) outlines a very disturbing incident which, if accurate, gets into the unsavory side of Apple, legitimate concerns regarding industrial espionage, and the occasional "partnership" between law enforcement and big-time corporate security officials.
The SF Weekly broke the story, which centers around the "disappearance" of an iPhone 5 prototype from a San Francisco bar. Apple, which had previously conducted a very high-profile hunt for an iPhone 4 prototype that appeared in gizmodo.com, apparently hit the corporate tilt button. That's where the story goes into streets that are darker than night, to paraphrase Raymond Chandler.
A number of troubling issues emerge from the article:
1. Apple tracked the phone "electronically". That capability implies your phone, whether turned on or off, could be used as a tracking device. No law covers your right to privacy in that case. Gadget creators and social media drum beaters distinctly downplay this issue. Not so in Europe, where Google, Facebook, and the smartphone players are running afoul of European Union privacy laws.
2. Apple security apparently accompanied San Francisco police officers in a search of a private residence. It was unclear whether the Apple personnel identified themselves as law enforcement officials, or intimated that they were officially connected to the San Francisco Police Department. (The San Francisco police department statement on the incident is quoted in its entirety in this linked LA Times blog post on the affair.)
3. Apple's high-handed security tactics reflect a need for control that goes beyond rationality. This perspective starts at the top, with Steve Jobs and his well-documented micromanaging style. Since the recent deification of Jobs into a corporate saint, and Apple's position as a "success story," Apple has gotten more or less a free pass from the media. Its outsourcing of manufacturing to cheap, environmentally unconscious Asian facilities should be a source of concern in an era of high domestic unemployment. Even the suicides and industrial accidents at Foxconn's Chinese facilities, where many Apple products are put into tangible form, were largely brushed aside. While Apple is hardly alone in this shameful practice, it also has dodged any sort of moral leadership in this area. Instead, one hears bromides about "game-changing" technology, "innovative" design, etc., as if that's all that mattered.
Privacy counts, even if Facebook's Mark Zuckerberg thinks it's a quaint notion (with queasy overtones of Alberto Gonzalez's similar characterization of the Geneva Convention). Complying with the law, rather than acting as if the corporation is above legal inconveniencies, is important. These are issues larger than the sanctity of a gadget.
However, there is reasonable concern regarding industrial espionage. Silicon Valley firms, which stand to lose enormously if their prize projects slip into competitors' hands, work hard to control instances of intellectual property theft. There are many interested players in this especially dark corner of enterprise: rival firms, hostile or friendly nation states, small-time pirates, even James Bond-style criminal enterprises. It's a tough neighborhood. In the case of Apple and the missing iPhone 5 prototype, the biggest issue is how the device got out of a very secure corporate building in the first place. That's one question Apple is unlikely to publicly discuss. After all, that would bring the investigation home.
Saturday, January 8, 2011
Economic Warfare School

In a widely reported story today, three key employees of the French car manufacturer Renault were suspended for their alleged involvement in industrial espionage. In the trio's cases, they were suspected to providing sensitive internal information about new electric car technology to representatives of foreign entities.
France is hardly a stranger to industrial espionage. The nation's political-industrial complex has been among the world leaders in conducting industrial spying, sharing leadership in this dubious category with Israel and Russia. The Renault case has turned the tables on the French. It has also brought attention to the People's Republic of China's clandestine efforts to obtain confidential industrial information. (It should be noted that a different perspective on the case was raised in an automotive news blog, which suggested in-house rivalries generated the "espionage," rather than James Bond-style international spy rings.)
One curious aspect of l'affaire Renault was a cogent comment from a representative of an institution called the Economic Warfare School of Paris. The institution, a splendid example of the close links between the French state and key French industries, trains its cadres in the art of economic ju-jitsu. Military experts are among the school's trainers. The school's thumbnail description leaves little mystery as to its purpose, and presumably one's probable career path. It's not as if one gets a job in this field through The New York Times classifieds.
What can the school's application form be like? One wonders how an applicant's professional recommendations are handled. And imagine one's surprise when walking into an office, and on the colleague's wall is a diploma from this unique French institution. Would the diploma be an ice-breaker or a conversation killer? And one should tread carefully on the topic of Renault's new line of electric cars.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)

