Showing posts with label Supreme Court. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Supreme Court. Show all posts

Sunday, November 6, 2011

Sandra Day O'Connor Going Strong at 81

Chief Justice Warren Burger Swearing In Sandra Day O'Connor, 1981
For a long time, I thought that Supreme Court justices were similar to popes. Their confidence in the strength of their own arguments paralleled a belief in their own legal infallibility. They all seemed ancient, as pontiffs do. Popes don't retire; the Supremes typically don't, either.

The refreshing exception was Sandra Day O'Connor. She retired to take care of her ailing husband. Her legal perspective came from a rancher's life, unique for top-tier judges and elite attorneys. (By contrast, four Supreme Court justices spent their formative years in New York City.) She was also the first female Supreme Court justice, placed into nomination by conservative Ronald Reagan.

The Washington Post ran a feature on O'Connor, with the lead noting her recent visit to the National Cowgirl Museum in Fort Worth, Texas. It's a good story to read, and includes her controversial advocacy for electing judges versus appointing them.

Monday, April 4, 2011

Supreme Court Ruling Adds to Assault on Public Schools

The Supreme Court, in a split decision reflecting its political schism, upheld the use of state tax credits that pay for children to attend religiously affiliated schools "cannot be challenged on constitutional grounds." The story from today's LA Times reviews the decision, the reactions of very interested parties, and the decision's likely impact on public and church schools.

The ruling continues a trend in which classist forces, such as Mike Bloomberg and Barack Obama, have found common ground with reactionary religious organizations and political conservatives. Both groups want the end of the public school system as we know it. The classists believe an education "crisis" exists which can only be solved through the erosion of teacher's union clout, the creation of "new" schools, and the need for "21st Century" curricula and instruction. In this effort, an entire generation of teachers has essentially been told to hit the road. Why? They're allegedly too expensive, indifferent to students, and unable to teach. Curiously, the people making this criticism may very well have been taught by the same instructors now given a collective dunce cap.

The right-wing doesn't like public schools on principle (no pun intended). Their mantra is "choice," though that slogan has become a Trojan horse for the taxpayer subsidy of religious education. Nothing good can result in the United States from state supported religion. The Supreme Court's conservative wing, with its intention to provide a legal foundation for the right-wing's moral agenda, produced a transparently specious line of reasoning to support a politically motivated decision.

The big losers are, again, teachers. The public schools will certainly be weakened; the religious schools can pay lower salaries and demand fealty to religious beliefs, while keeping their hand out for taxpayer funding.

Wednesday, June 30, 2010

Three Hearings

Three hearings were held today that revealed some curious things about the state of the United States. I'll provide links for each of them.

First up -- Joe Cassano, former master of the universe/AIG derivatives division. Best part was Cassano's $280 million compensation over an eight-year period, plus $1 million/month salary paid by AIG for his "consultant" work for the firm after he was no longer on AIG staff. Bloomberg story is best of the bunch; NY Times' is by far the weakest.

Next up -- Porn stars testified in a Los Angeles hearing that using condoms during filming would cramp their style. According to the LA Times story, one porn actor said "If you're worried or paranoid, you should not be in this industry."

And then -- Elena Kagan in a genuinely funny moment at her Senate committee confirmation hearings. The Talking Points Memo story includes the relevant dialogue between Senator Lindsay Graham and Supreme Court nominee Kagan.